BREAKING NEWS: Collin County Issues Stunning Verdict in Karmelo Anthony Case — Death Penalty Handed Down After Teen’s Fatal Stabbing
Collin County delivered a dramatic conclusion today in the high-profile murder trial of 22-year-old Karmelo Anthony, sentencing him to death for the killing of 17-year-old student athlete Austin Metcalf.
A Crime That Shook the Community
Metcalf was found fatally stabbed on a Plano street last March. Anthony, a local youth coach who knew him through sports programs, was arrested hours later. Prosecutors argued the killing was premeditated, fueled by long-building resentment and a personal dispute involving Anthony’s sister.
Evidence That Led to Conviction
Surveillance footage, text messages hinting at retaliation, and a bloodstained hoodie found in Anthony’s home all played key roles in the trial. The jury also saw video of Anthony’s emotional confession, though he insisted he hadn’t intended to kill Metcalf.
After brief deliberation, jurors found him guilty of capital murder.
Remembering Austin Metcalf
Metcalf, a well-loved high school football captain, was remembered by coaches, classmates, and his grieving parents as a hardworking and kind young man with a bright future.
“You took our son’s entire life from him,” his mother said during sentencing.
The Defense Responds
Anthony’s attorneys called the ruling “devastating,” citing years of untreated mental health issues and promising to appeal, including challenging his competency during trial.
Renewed Debate Over Capital Punishment
The case has once again intensified discussions about the death penalty in Texas. Reform advocates condemned the sentence, while many locals felt it delivered justice for a particularly brutal crime.
Two Families Altered Forever
Metcalf’s parents continue to mourn their son, while Anthony’s family is said to be struggling privately with the outcome.
Before the judge issued the ruling, Anthony addressed the victim’s family directly:
“I wish I could take it back. I pray for your son every day.”
The judge’s response was brief and final:
“The law has spoken.”
Outside the courthouse, silence hung over a community still trying to make sense of a tragedy that left no winners — only loss on all sides.