Authorities Expand Investigation with Search at Savannah Guthrie’s Sister’s Home
The search for Nancy Guthrie has escalated from a local missing-person case to a nationally followed investigation. In February 2026, law enforcement intensified their efforts in Tucson, Arizona, conducting an extensive, multi-hour search at the home of Annie Guthrie, Savannah Guthrie’s sister, and her husband, Tommaso Cioni. The operation involved both local deputies and federal agents, marking a critical development in the ongoing inquiry into the disappearance of the 84-year-old matriarch.
Reporters on the scene described a tense atmosphere as forensic teams worked methodically inside the residence, documenting evidence and collecting items with blue latex gloves. Although authorities have not named any family members as suspects, the scrutiny reflects standard investigative procedures when the last known movements of a missing person are being reconstructed.
Nancy Guthrie was last seen leaving for dinner with family, returning home in the company of Tommaso Cioni, the last person reportedly to see her. Her absence the following morning triggered concern, especially after her wallet and phone were found at home, alongside traces of blood. Subsequent investigative measures have included towing a vehicle from her property for analysis and an FBI-led reward of $50,000 for information regarding her whereabouts.
Cryptic notes sent to both the family and media outlets, hinting at ransom or extortion, added urgency and emotional strain. Savannah Guthrie publicly addressed the messages, appealing for her mother’s safe return while emphasizing the family’s commitment to follow instructions to ensure her safety. A reported deadline in the messages further intensified the pressure on authorities and the family.
The arrest of Derrick Callella shifted investigative focus toward a potential criminal element, though details about his connection to Nancy Guthrie remain limited as investigators continue examining evidence linking the blood at her home to the extortion notes.
While public attention remains divided across global news and social media, the Guthrie case stands out for its deeply human stakes. The forensic search at Annie Guthrie’s residence highlights the meticulous work involved in unraveling complex disappearances, from documenting potential evidence to analyzing unexplained electronic signals linked to the case.
As investigators continue to review evidence and question the newly detained Callella, the Guthrie family remains in limbo, navigating the emotional and procedural challenges of a high-profile investigation. The ongoing efforts in Tucson underscore the persistence required to uncover the truth, pursue justice, and, ultimately, provide answers for a family desperate for closure.