The quiet of a typical Arizona evening quickly gave way to a nationwide FBI search for 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie in just one Saturday night. For Savannah Guthrie, the “Today” show host, February 2026 has been overshadowed by a personal crisis that escalated from a missing-persons case to a full-scale forensic investigation into a possible abduction. As of February 23, 2026, Nancy’s disappearance from her Tucson home has revealed chilling details, leaving her family in turmoil and the community deeply unsettled.
In response, the Guthrie family has largely stayed out of the public eye, adopting a strategy of privacy to focus on recovery efforts. For the first time since Nancy went missing, Savannah’s sister, Annie Guthrie, and her husband, Tommaso Cioni, were seen publicly. Photographs taken in Tucson show the couple weighed down by the intense media attention and the stress of an unfolding tragedy.
A Chilling Investigation
Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance began with a welfare check after she missed Sunday church services. Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos confirmed the home is now a crime scene, with signs of forced entry and a blood trail leading from the front door. Nancy, who has serious health issues including a pacemaker and high blood pressure, is dependent on regular medication, raising concerns about her wellbeing. Theories of kidnapping are reinforced by a ransom note sent to a local news outlet, containing details about her home and attire that indicate insider knowledge.
Tommaso Cioni, Annie’s husband, reportedly was the last family member to see Nancy alive, dropping her off after a Saturday dinner around 9:30 p.m. While authorities emphasize that the family is fully cooperating, this timeline places them at the center of initial investigations. When Annie and Tommaso were spotted on Tuesday, they appeared weary and guarded, navigating the media frenzy as grief-stricken relatives rather than public figures.
National Attention
The case has drawn attention well beyond Arizona. Savannah Guthrie stepped back from her “Today” show duties and officially withdrew from hosting the 2026 Winter Olympics in Italy, prioritizing her family’s crisis. Her husband, Michael Feldman, has become the family spokesperson, carefully managing public statements to prevent speculation from interfering with the investigation. Savannah has asked her audience for prayers and trust during this difficult time.
Forensic Search Intensifies
By the fourth day, investigators expanded their search to Nancy’s property and its surroundings. Reports indicate forensic teams are investigating potential clues in the garden, though officials have not confirmed any link to her location. The FBI’s involvement signals the case’s seriousness, given the ransom note and signs of struggle, with federal resources including satellite tracking and canine units deployed to aid in the search.
Family Resilience Amid Crisis
Savannah, Annie, and sibling Camron are relying on one another for support, balancing public scrutiny with private grief. Sheriff Nanos described the family as “leaning on each other,” a critical dynamic as the investigation transitions from missing person to potential abduction. Nancy’s age, medical needs, and vulnerability highlight the case’s urgency and the stakes involved.
As the Winter Olympics begin in Italy, Savannah’s absence underscores the personal toll of the investigation. Meanwhile, authorities and the public watch closely, hoping for news of Nancy Guthrie’s safe return.
Context of Senior Abductions in 2026
-
82% of elderly abduction cases with ransom demands are resolved within 72–96 hours.
-
15% of such cases involve forced entry in affluent rural areas.
-
Federal recovery efforts see a 94% success rate when early forensic GPS tracking and fail-safes are used.
The search continues, keeping the nation’s attention on the desert hills of Tucson as the family and investigators await a breakthrough.